Pin it
Tasty Deviled Egg Pasta Salad: Where Two Favorites Meet
This Deviled Egg Pasta Salad brings together the best of two worlds. It mixes the rich taste of deviled eggs with hearty pasta for a dish that'll wow everyone at your next get-together.
I got tired of bringing plain old deviled eggs to family parties. The first time I tried this mash-up at our reunion, even my nephew (who usually hates eggs) couldn't stop eating it.
Key Ingredients
- Elbow Macaroni: These little curved noodles hold all the yummy sauce perfectly
- Fresh Eggs: Pick eggs you've had for about a week since newer ones don't peel as well
- Quality Mayonnaise: Don't skimp here - regular fat mayo makes everything taste better
- Dijon Mustard: Gives that fancy zip that makes the whole dish pop
- White Vinegar: Wakes up all the flavors without tasting sour
- Celery: Adds that must-have crunch and garden-fresh taste
- Red Onion: Brings pretty purple color and nice sharp flavor
- Paprika: Mix some in your dressing and sprinkle on top for that classic look
Step-By-Step Cooking Guide
- Getting Perfect Eggs (12-15 minutes):
- Start eggs in cold water. Let them reach a gentle boil, cover the pot, and take it off the heat. Wait exactly 12 minutes. Put eggs straight into ice water. Shell them under running water for best results.
- Cooking Your Pasta (8-10 minutes):
- Make your pasta water really salty - it should taste like ocean water. Cook pasta until it's soft but not mushy. Rinse with cold water after draining. Lay it out on a baking sheet to cool down. Mix with a tiny splash of oil so it won't stick together.
- Making The Dressing (5-7 minutes):
- Cut eggs and pop out the yolks. Squish yolks completely with a fork. Stir in mayo until it looks smooth. Add your mustard, vinegar and spices. Give it a taste and fix the flavor before mixing with pasta. Let sit 5 minutes so flavors can blend.
- Putting It All Together (10 minutes):
- Cut egg whites into small chunks. Chop celery and onion into tiny pieces. Mix cold pasta with your dressing. Gently stir in egg whites and veggies. Add more spices if needed. Chill at least 2 hours.
- Last Touches:
- Dust with paprika to make it pretty. Add fresh herbs if you want. Crack some more pepper on top if needed. Let sit out for 10 minutes before people dig in.
Pin it
My grandma always told me that taking your time with the egg yolks was the key to amazing deviled eggs. They need to be super smooth. This same trick makes this pasta salad great too - hurrying never works out well.
Advice From The Pros
- Keep some extra dressing on the side to perk up the salad later
- Never use cold mayo straight from the fridge - let it warm up first
- Chop all your veggies super tiny for the best texture
- Try using a grater on your onion instead of knife for stronger flavor without the chunks
Pin it
Prep-Ahead Plan
After many potlucks, I've figured out how to break up the work:
- Boil eggs up to 3 days early
- Cook pasta a day ahead
- Mix dressing by itself and keep in fridge
- Cut veggies and store them separately
- Mix everything together no more than 8 hours before you'll eat it
Fixing Common Problems
- If it seems too dry: Mix some more mayo and mustard and stir it in
- If eggs won't peel: Use older eggs and peel them under running water
- If your dressing has lumps: Push egg yolks through a strainer
- If it tastes boring: Add a bit more mustard and some salt
Keeping It Fresh
Getting the storage right keeps this salad tasting great:
- Always keep in the fridge below 40°F
- Use containers with tight-fitting lids
- Will stay good for about 3 days
- Don't try to freeze it - ever
What To Serve With It
- Barbecued meat or fish
- Garden-fresh veggies
- Soft, warm bread
- A bowl of light soup for lunch
This Deviled Egg Pasta Salad has become my go-to dish for gatherings. It takes the warm feelings of traditional deviled eggs and turns them into something more practical. I love watching people's faces light up when they try it at backyard parties and holiday dinners - they always want to know how I made it.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long before serving can I prep it?
- You can prepare it up to a day ahead. Add a little milk or mayo later if it dries out.
- → What's the best kind of mayo to use?
- A full-fat option like Hellman's or Best Foods works best for the right flavor and consistency.
- → Can I switch the pasta type?
- Of course! Bow tie, shells, rotini, or other medium-sized shapes are all good choices instead of elbow macaroni.
- → How long can I store the leftovers?
- Keep it in the fridge in a sealed container, where it'll stay good for around four days.
- → Why should I rinse pasta in cold water?
- It halts cooking and cools the pasta quickly so it's ready to be mixed with your other ingredients.