Creamy Rice Pudding

This homemade stovetop Rice Pudding turns basic kitchen staples into the ultimate comfort bowl. Every bite offers velvety, tender rice soaked with sweet vanilla and warming cinnamon notes. The rich brown sugar gives it complexity while juicy raisins scatter tiny pops of sweetness throughout. It's the kind of treat that feels like a warm blanket on a cold day.

I tweaked this recipe over many chilly nights, learning that taking your time and staying watchful really matters. Even my grandma, who keeps her best cooking tricks to herself, had to admit this version stands up to her old family method.

Key Ingredients

• Short-grain Rice: The higher starch makes for that dreamy, smooth consistency. Try using Arborio for best results.
• Whole Milk: Delivers that silky, luxurious base. Don't skimp on fat content for the right texture.
• Dark Brown Sugar: Brings those deep, molasses-like flavors that white sugar just can't deliver.
• Fresh Vanilla: Real extract seriously upgrades the overall taste profile.
• Large Egg: Works as a natural thickener while boosting the richness factor.

Pin it

Foolproof Method

Getting Going:

Mix milk with rice in a thick-bottomed saucepan. Warm it slowly, giving it an occasional stir. Look for tiny bubbles forming around the edges. Turn down the heat right when you see bubbling begin.

The Important Middle Part:

Stir often but gently so nothing sticks. Notice how the rice slowly puffs up and softens. Keep the flame low and steady - don't rush it. You'll see the milk gradually thicken up and reduce down.

Making It Richer:

Beat together egg and sugar in another bowl until smooth. Slowly pour in some hot rice mixture while constantly stirring. This careful step stops the egg from cooking too fast. Pour everything back into your pot with gentle heat.

Finishing Touches:

Mix in vanilla and cinnamon toward the end of cooking time. Toss in raisins if you want them. Keep cooking until it's as thick as you like, knowing it'll thicken more as it cools.

After making this pudding countless times, I've noticed that using good quality milk really changes everything. Fresh whole milk from local farms gives a uniquely luxurious feel that turns this simple dessert into something truly memorable.

Watching Your Heat

Getting the temperature just right throughout cooking makes all the difference. Too hot and you'll burn the milk or scramble the egg. Too cool and your rice won't soften properly. Using a heavy pot really helps keep the heat nice and steady.

Prep It Early

This pudding actually tastes better the next day after all the flavors have had time to mix together. I usually make mine the night before I plan to serve it, putting plastic wrap right on the surface to keep a skin from forming.

After trying so many different versions, I think this rice pudding hits just the right balance between easy and fancy. Serve it warm when it's cold outside or chilled during hot weather - it works beautifully either way. The gentle sweetness and smooth, creamy texture make it a forever favorite that everyone from kids to grandparents will enjoy.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Why is short grain rice used?

It gives off more starch, making everything extra creamy.

→ What’s the deal with tempering eggs?

Tempering helps mix eggs in smoothly without scrambling them.

→ Can I store it ahead of time?

Definitely! It’s great cold or warm. Just remember, it’ll firm up as it sits.

→ Why is it watery while hot?

That’s normal. Once it cools, the texture becomes thicker and creamier.

→ Can I switch up the milk?

Sure! Though whole milk is perfectly creamy, alternatives might change the texture.