Pin it
This comforting dish blends the rich tastes of French onion soup with a classic potato bake. Sweet, slowly-cooked onions and soft potato slices come together under a gooey cheese topping. Every mouthful gives you creamy potatoes, sweet onions, and melty cheese in perfect harmony.
I've tried this dish many ways, and I've found that spending the extra time to slowly cook the onions until they're super sweet and golden brown really takes the whole thing to another level.
Smart Ingredient Picking Guide
- Potatoes: Go for russets as they soak up all the flavor but still keep their shape
- Onions: Stick with yellow ones for that perfect mix of sweet and savory
- Gruyère: Real Swiss Gruyère has that nutty taste and melts beautifully
- Mozzarella: Gives you those amazing cheese pulls without taking over the flavor
- Heavy cream: Don't skimp here - full-fat makes everything super smooth
- Fresh thyme: Adds that perfect herby touch that brings everything together
Pin it
Easy-to-Follow Cooking Steps
- Getting those perfect onions:
- Cut onions the same size for even cooking. Start them on medium heat to get the moisture out. Turn down the heat once they start to color. Don't stir too much. Add a bit of salt to help get the moisture going. Keep cooking until they're deep golden brown.
- Getting the potatoes ready:
- Clean and peel your potatoes. A mandoline works best for even slices. Soak them in cold water until you need them. Make sure they're completely dry before you use them. Season each layer as you go.
- Building your layers:
- Start with a thin cream layer at the bottom. Put potato slices down with a bit of overlap. Spread some caramelized onions on top. Pour cream slowly over everything. Add your cheese mix. Keep doing this and finish with cheese on top.
- Cooking it through:
- Cover tightly with foil. Cook at the right temp. Take the foil off at the right moment. Check it's done by poking with a knife. Let it sit before serving.
Over my years making potato bakes, I've found that taking your time is what makes all the difference. The effort you put into slowly cooking those onions and carefully building your layers really shows up in how amazing the final dish tastes.
Mastering Heat Control
Getting the temperature right matters:
- Cook onions on medium first, then lower the heat
- 375°F works perfectly for cooking the potatoes
- Use foil to stop the top from browning too soon
- Take off the foil at the right time for a golden top
Prep-Ahead Options
This dish is great for planning ahead:
- Cook your onions up to 3 days early
- Cut potatoes the day before and keep them in water
- Put the whole thing together and keep in the fridge
- Let it warm up a bit before baking
Fixing Common Problems
If sauce seems runny: Put more cheese on top. If some potatoes cook faster than others: Try to cut more even slices next time. If the top gets too brown: Just cover it with foil again. If the middle isn't cooking through: Your oven might need temperature checking.
Pin it
After making this French Onion Potato Bake so many times, I've grown to love how it brings together two amazing food traditions. The way the cream mixes with those sweet onions while the potatoes turn soft creates something truly special. It doesn't matter if you're making it for a weeknight dinner or a special occasion - this dish shows that when you treat simple ingredients with a little love and care, you can make something that's really outstanding.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prepare it in advance?
- Yep, you can put it together a day ahead, store it in the fridge, and pop it in the oven when it’s time to eat.
- → Why are the potatoes sliced thinly?
- Thin, even slices—about 1/8 inch—help everything cook at the same time and keep the texture just right.
- → Is there a good cheese swap?
- Swiss works well if Gruyere isn’t available, but Gruyere really nails the French onion flavor.
- → Do I need to peel the potatoes?
- It’s up to you! Peeling gives a smoother texture, but leaving the skins on adds a bit more rustic taste.
- → How can I stop the top from overcooking?
- Cover with foil while baking and only remove it during the last 15 minutes to finish crisping up the onions.