Pin it
Merge the luxury of scampi with the heartiness of filled shells in this inventive spin on two beloved dishes. Every shell delivers juicy chicken bathed in a rich white wine and citrus sauce, all smothered with perfectly gooey cheese for a stunning yet doable family meal.
One night when I couldn't decide between cozy food and something fancier, I threw scampi flavors into stuffed shells. The way those pasta pockets caught all that sauce while keeping the chicken chunks safe inside was a game-changer.
Key Components
- Large Pasta Shells: Need substantial size for filling
- Chicken Tenders: Keep juicy during cooking
- Raw Garlic: Gives that unmistakable scampi kick
- Good White Wine: Forms the foundation of your sauce
- Whole Lemon: We'll use both juice and outer peel
- Heavy Cream: Brings velvety texture to sauce
- Cheese Trio: Each brings something unique to the mix
- Green Parsley: Adds freshness at the end
Step-By-Step Guide
- Getting Shells Ready (15 minutes):
- Fill big pot with water and bring to boil. Add plenty of salt. Cook shells just under al dente. They'll finish while baking. Drain and let cool a bit. Be gentle so they don't split.
- Whipping Up Chicken and Sauce (20 minutes):
- Cut chicken into tiny, even chunks. Add plenty of seasonings. Cook until barely done. Take chicken out and save it. Drop butter in the same pan. Cook garlic until it smells amazing. Pour in wine and let it bubble down halfway. Stir in cream and spices. Let it thicken up.
- Putting It Together (10 minutes):
- Combine chicken with some of your cheese. Add a splash of sauce to the mix. Check flavor and add more if needed. Cool it slightly before handling. Spread sauce on baking dish bottom. Stuff each shell carefully. Arrange them in your dish.
- Baking To Perfection (15-20 minutes):
- Drizzle remaining sauce over stuffed shells. Sprinkle cheese blend on top. Cover with foil but don't seal tight. Bake till bubbling. Take foil off to brown the top. Wait a few minutes before digging in.
Pin it
I found my stuffed shell breakthrough when I started letting the pasta cool just enough to work with - too cold and they won't bend properly, too hot and you'll end up with torn shells everywhere.
Expert Cooking Wisdom
- Boil a few extra shells as backups
- Skip pre-shredded cheese for better melt
- Save some pasta water to fix thick sauce
- Don't use cold cream straight from fridge
Plan-Ahead Options
- Fix and fill shells a day before serving
- Make sauce but keep it apart
- Keep prepped shells covered in fridge
- Let sit on counter before cooking
- Pour sauce on just before baking time
Pin it
Tasty Companions
- Fresh garden salad
- Oven-roasted asparagus spears
- Buttery garlic toast
- Chilled Pinot Grigio
Tasty Twists
- Swap chicken for plump shrimp
- Experiment with new cheese blends
- Tuck some spinach into filling
- Mix in bits of sun-dried tomato
- Go bold with hot Italian sausage
These Chicken Scampi Stuffed Shells show how merging two favorites can create something that outshines the originals. Whether it's for a special gathering or just Tuesday dinner, it combines the fanciness of scampi with the huggable comfort of stuffed shells. Every time I cook this, I'm reminded that the most unforgettable meals often come from getting creative with familiar favorites.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What wine is best for cooking?
- Go for a dry white wine that's good enough to drink since it intensifies as it cooks.
- → Can I switch up the cheeses?
- Of course, try mixes like cheddar, monterey jack, or mozzarella.
- → What does pasta water do?
- It makes the sauce smooth and helps it stick better to the pasta.
- → Is this make-ahead friendly?
- You can prepare the stuffed shells in advance, but add the sauce and bake fresh.
- → Why use leftover seasoning?
- It gives the scampi sauce an extra punch of flavor.