Pin it
Sunday gravy doesn't need to break the bank—this pot roast version packs amazing flavor while keeping costs down. The mix of fork-tender beef, zesty Italian sausage, and thick tomato sauce comes together for a pasta topping that'll make you forget all about the time it takes to simmer.
When I first tried using cheap pot roast instead of pricey short ribs in my Sunday gravy, I couldn't believe how tasty it turned out. It's now my favorite way to whip up an impressive Italian meal without emptying my wallet.
Key Components
- Chuck Roast: Look for good marbling throughout
- Italian Sausage: Brings extra flavor and kick
- San Marzano Tomatoes: They're pricier but worth every penny
Step-By-Step Process
- Getting Your Meat Ready (15 minutes):
- Slice roast into similar-sized chunks. Add plenty of salt and pepper. Cook meat in small batches until brown. Take out and put aside. Cook sausage pieces next. Leave the tasty fat in your pot.
- Creating Flavor Foundation (10 minutes):
- Throw onions in the same pot. Cook till see-through. Drop in garlic and carrots. Mix in celery. Sprinkle herbs and spices. Wait for veggies to get soft.
- Letting Magic Happen (4-5 hours):
- Dump in tomatoes and paste. Add your red wine. Put meat back in pot. Let it bubble gently. Move to oven. Cook until meat shreds easily.
- Putting It All Together (20 minutes):
- Pull apart meat right in the sauce. Boil pasta till firm but not hard. Save some pasta water. Slowly mix in cream. Combine pasta with your sauce. Add pasta water if needed.
Pin it
In my family, Sunday sauce always called for fancy meat cuts, but finding out how amazingly pot roast works changed the game completely. The beef gets so soft it basically disappears into the sauce, making something truly unforgettable.
Keeping And Using Extras
- This sauce tastes even better tomorrow and handles freezing like a champ
- Cook extra and split into smaller portions for quick future dinners
- Use leftovers in stuffed peppers, baked pasta dishes or on sandwiches
Drink Matches And Serving Ideas
Pin it
- Goes great with bold reds like Chianti or Montepulciano
- Put out some crusty bread for sauce sopping
- Serve with a basic green salad dressed with good oil and balsamic
Expert Kitchen Tricks
- Cook meat in smaller amounts for better browning
- Keep sauce barely bubbling throughout cooking
- Use saved pasta cooking water to fix thickness
Fun Twists To Try
- Throw in some mushrooms for extra umami
- Add a dash of balsamic at the end for zing
- Mix in red pepper flakes if you want some heat
Planning Ahead
- Make your sauce up to three days before serving
- Warm it up slowly, adding water or cream if it's too thick
- Cook it on Friday for the best Sunday flavor
Party Portions
- Make twice as much sauce but keep pasta amount the same
- Offer some charred veggies and good bread on the side
- Let folks add their own cheese, pepper flakes, and fresh herbs
This Pot Roast Sunday Sauce shows me that sometimes the cheapest ingredients make the most amazing food. Whether you're cooking for your family or hosting friends, this sauce pulls everyone to the table—and isn't that what matters most on Sunday?
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's the reason for cooking so long?
- It gives the meat time to soften and allows the flavors to meld beautifully.
- → Is star anise necessary?
- Nope, it’s optional. But it does add a nice hint of depth.
- → Why are San Marzano tomatoes important?
- They're naturally sweeter and not as tangy, so the sauce turns out richer.
- → Can I prepare this early?
- Definitely. The flavor actually gets better when it sits overnight.
- → What kind of wine should I use?
- A bold red like Cabernet Sauvignon or Chianti works great!