Italian Chicken Panini

Nothing beats a hearty Italian chicken panini with its crunchy bread, gooey cheese, and flavorful pesto all wrapped in one tasty package. This sandwich turns everyday items into a café-worthy treat that brings authentic Italian tastes with every mouthful. When tender chicken meets sweet fire-roasted peppers and melty mozzarella, you'll feel like you're sitting at a sideways table in Italy. Each component works together to build amazing flavor that just can't be beat.

I stumbled on this recipe while trying to make the Italian sandwiches I love from cafés at home. After trying loads of different combos, this one came out on top. The secret's in picking good ingredients and handling each one with a bit of love. These days, this panini brings my family running to the kitchen on weekends, drawn in by the amazing smell.

Stunning Ingredients

• Italian bread: Go for bread with a nice crunchy outside and soft middle. Cut slices about 1/2 inch thick so they don't fall apart when pressed. Bread that's a day old actually works better because it stands up to heat and pressure
• Fresh mozzarella: Don't use the pre-shredded stuff - get real, fresh mozzarella that'll give you that amazing stringy cheese pull. Cut it into even slices so it all melts the same way
• Basil pesto: Homemade or from the store, just make sure it's bright green and smells fresh. You want it thick enough to spread without making your bread wet. Fresh pesto has oils and flavors you just can't get from dried herbs
• Chicken breast: Freshly cooked or grabbed from a rotisserie chicken both work. Cut it thin across the grain for tender bites. Season it well but don't go overboard
• Red onions: Slice them super thin so they don't take over. Soak them in cold water for 10 minutes to take away some bite while keeping them crunchy
• Roasted red peppers: The ones in jars with oil taste best. Make sure to dry them completely before using or you'll end up with soggy bread. Cut them into skinny strips for easier eating
• Seasonings: Fresh black pepper and sea salt bring out all the other flavors. A sprinkle of Italian herbs can make everything taste even better

Building Your Delicious Panini

Getting Ready:

Start by putting all your stuff out to reach room temperature so everything melts and tastes better together. This little step that many people skip really changes how good your sandwich turns out. Room temp ingredients mix together way better and make a more unified sandwich. Don't rush the prep work. Get your onions super thin with a sharp knife. Use paper towels to really dry those roasted peppers or you'll end up with wet bread. Cut your chicken against the grain into pieces that'll spread evenly across your bread.

Putting It Together:

Spread lots of pesto on both bread pieces, going all the way to the edges. This makes a tasty shield that keeps your bread from getting soggy. Stack your ingredients in the right order - chicken first, then neatly arranged peppers, followed by those paper-thin onions, and finish with evenly spaced mozzarella slices. This order makes sure everything stays put while cooking and gives you perfect flavor in each bite.

Pressing It Right:

Get your panini press nice and hot before you start. Having it properly heated gives you those pretty grill marks and melts everything evenly. Brush some olive oil or spray cooking spray on the surfaces. Put your sandwich right in the middle of the press. Close the top gently and let the weight of the press do the work. Don't push down too hard or all your fillings will squeeze out the sides.

Pin it

I've made so many paninis that I've learned being patient and paying attention to small details really matters. The first time I hurried, my sandwich came out uneven with hard cheese spots. Now I take my time with every step, knowing I'll get something amazing in the end.

Tasty Twists

Change up this sandwich by trying different Italian cheeses like provolone or fontina. Throw in some sundried tomatoes for big flavor, or add fresh basil leaves for a pop of freshness. If you like heat, mix in some pepperoncini or hot cherry peppers.

Keeping It Fresh

These sandwiches taste way better right after they're made, but you can prep the ingredients ahead of time. Keep everything sliced and stored separately in containers. Put it all together just before cooking for best results. If you need to save a cooked sandwich, wrap it in foil and warm it slowly in a cool oven to keep the outside crispy.

After making this sandwich countless times, I've realized it's so much more than just food. It's Italian cooking tradition made simple for regular home cooks. Whether you're making a fast lunch or feeding friends, these paninis bring a taste of Italian café life straight to your kitchen table.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Do I have to own a panini press?

It’s helpful, but a heavy skillet pressing the sandwich in a regular pan works too.

→ Which chicken is the best option?

Use any cooked chicken—rotisserie, leftovers, or freshly prepared chicken breast.

→ Is it good to make ahead?

Prepare ingredients early, but wait to put it together and cook until it’s time to eat.

→ What bread should I go for?

Italian bread is great, but any firm, crusty bread that handles pressing is just fine.

→ Are extra ingredients an option?

Sure! Toss in some tomatoes, fresh basil, or switch up the cheese to match your taste.