Pin it
Whip up this tangy twist on traditional tartar sauce where regular mayo transforms into a creamy, zesty topping that'll make seafood dishes taste amazing. Every component works together for that perfect flavor mix - the crunchy pickles, the fresh herbs, it all comes together beautifully.
After making this sauce many times, I've found that cutting the pickles by hand, not buzzing them in a processor, gives you the best texture with little pickle surprises in every bite.
Complete Ingredient Picking Guide
- Mayonnaise: Full-fat mayo only, skip the light stuff or miracle whip
- Dill pickles: Go for kosher dill for superior taste
- Fresh herbs: Pick vibrant green dill or parsley with no yellow spots
- Lemon juice: Only use freshly squeezed
- Onion: Go with sweet or yellow types, chopped super tiny
- Sugar: Just a touch to cut through the sour notes
Pin it
Straightforward Preparation Guide
- Pickle preparation:
- Make sure pickles are well-drained. Chop them small but not mushy. Squeeze between paper towels. Keep pieces similar sized. Don't use a food processor.
- Herb preparation:
- Cut off the stems from dill or parsley. Chop right before you mix everything. Measure after you've chopped them. Save a pinch for garnishing. Blot dry if they're wet.
- Mixing technique:
- Use mayo that's not cold from the fridge. Mix in other stuff bit by bit. Stir gently to blend. Give it a taste and fix the seasoning. Wait a while before serving.
From my experience making tons of tartar sauce batches, I've noticed that good ingredients really matter. Using proper mayo and fresh herbs turns this from a basic sauce into something really special.
Time-Saving Prep Tricks
This sauce gets even better over time:
- Keeps well for up to 5 days when refrigerated
- Tastes improve as ingredients blend together
- Set out for a few minutes before serving
- Keep in a sealed container
Creative Twists
Put your own spin on it with these ideas:
- Throw in some capers for extra tang
- Mix in fresh garlic for kick
- Switch up your pickle varieties
- Try different fresh herbs
Fixing Common Problems
Too runny: Squeeze more moisture from pickles. Too stiff: Add a tiny splash of pickle juice. Too sour: Put in a bit more sugar. Too flat: Sprinkle in extra pepper or lemon.
Pin it
After spending years getting this recipe just right, I've learned it's all about balance. The smooth mayo base pairs with tangy pickles while the herbs add freshness, creating the ultimate seafood companion. Whether you're dunking fish fingers or dolloping it on crab patties, this homemade tartar sauce shows that taking a few minutes to make your own is totally worth it.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long will this sauce last in the fridge?
- Keep it in a covered container in the fridge for no more than a week.
- → Can dried herbs be swapped in?
- Fresh herbs are best, but you can use dried ones. Just use about a third of the fresh amount.
- → What’s the best mayo to use?
- Stick with full-fat, real mayonnaise for the silkiest sauce.
- → Do I have to use sugar?
- You don’t have to, but a pinch of sugar balances the tartness from the pickles and lemon.
- → Which type of pickles work best?
- Go with dill pickles for the classic taste. Skip sweet ones.