Pin it
These two-bite wonders combine velvety cheesecake filling with soft red velvet cake crumbs, creating an addictive treat that'll disappear at any gathering faster than you can say "seconds please."
After testing batch after batch, I found that letting the butter and cream cheese sit out until totally soft is the game-changer for getting that silky-smooth filling everyone raves about.
Smart Ingredient Picking Guide
- Cream cheese: Get the full-fat kind and let it warm up completely
- Red velvet cake mix: Pick whatever brand you spot at the store
- Graham crackers: Crush them super fine while they're crisp
- Butter: Use the unsalted kind, left out till completely soft
- Powdered sugar: Run it through a strainer for no lumps
- Vanilla: Go for real extract for the yummiest result
Pin it
Simple Follow-Along Instructions
- Get the cake ready:
- Make it just like the box says. Let it cool all the way down. Break it into tiny bits by hand. Try to make all pieces about the same size. Put them aside for later.
- Mix up your filling:
- Whip the cream cheese till it's fluffy. Slowly drop in the butter while mixing. Sprinkle in sugar bit by bit. Stir in vanilla and crushed crackers. Stick it in the fridge a little while.
- Shape your treats:
- Scoop out even amounts. Roll them into nice balls. Cool them till firm. Coat them in the cake bits. Press the crumbs in lightly so they stick.
I learned the hard way that rushing through the cooling steps ruins these treats. Taking your time between stages pays off with perfectly shaped bites that won't fall apart.
Timing Matters
Watch your clock for best results:
- Let dairy stuff warm up on the counter (about an hour)
- Cool the filling for half an hour before you scoop it
- Pop the balls in the freezer for 15 mins before coating
- Store in the fridge until you're ready to serve
Do-Ahead Options
Save time by planning ahead:
- Get the cake made and crumbled up to 3 days early
- Whip up the filling the night before
- Roll and coat the balls the day you'll eat them
- Finished treats stay good in the fridge for 5 days
Fixing Common Problems
Too mushy? Chill them longer between steps. Crumbs falling off? Press a bit harder while rolling. Weird shapes? Try using a cookie scoop. Filling too runny? Toss in more crushed graham crackers.
Pin it
After making these bites dozens of times, I've realized their magic isn't just about good ingredients but how they work together. The tangy filling plays so well with the hint of cocoa in the red velvet coating. They're crowd-pleasers at fancy dinners or casual potlucks, showing that the tastiest treats don't always need to be big and fancy. Sometimes the little bites pack the biggest punch!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make them sweeter?
- Absolutely! Add up to an extra cup of powdered sugar if you'd like a more sugary flavor.
- → Why dry the crumbs?
- It helps avoid a soggy coating, as moist crumbs could ruin their texture during storage.
- → How long will they last?
- Keep them refrigerated in a sealed container, and they'll stay fresh for about five days.
- → Can I freeze these?
- Yes, pop them in an airtight container and freeze for three months. Let them thaw in the fridge when you're ready to eat.
- → What’s the deal with room temp ingredients?
- Softened butter and cream cheese mix way better, giving you a smoother, creamier result.